Students and citizenship

Lord Goldsmith's much-reported recent idea that pupils should take an oath of allegiance to Queen and country seems all very well on the surface, but as will most of these news stories, there's a sinister undertone if you read between the lines. If this is all about encouraging teenagers to be good citizens then there's a serious failure in this quote from Lord Goldsmith:
The citizenship ceremonies, which are just one of the many things I have suggested, are a way of marking that passage of being a student of citizenship to a citizen in practice.
What this is saying is that students are not teenagers aren't citizens at all while they're in full-time education, and therefore don't count and aren't expected to display adult behaviour until after they leave school. Calling someone a second-class citizen, or, worse, no citizen at all, is a sure way of arousing rebelliousness and stirring up trouble. Such a careless choice of words can only serve to further alienate Britain's teenagers and consequently result in more anti-social behaviour, not less.

We seem to have gone from one extreme, where every word that any politician said was spin-doctored to death, to another, where politicians don't think at all before they open their mouths.

Related link: